Who would …? Who wouldn't …? ai mà, ai lại không
rhetorical who
Pattern: Ai mà + [verb]? · Ai lại không + [verb]? · [topic] thì ai không + [verb]?
B1 · estimatespoken
Typed without accents: ai ma, ai lai khong
Some questions with ai (who) don't ask anything. Said with feeling, Ai mà biết! means "Who knows!", that is, nobody does. Mà after ai gives the question a "who on earth would …" sense, and the answer it expects is "nobody": Ai mà ngờ được! Who'd have thought it!
Add không, and the expected answer becomes "everybody": Ai lại không thương con mình? Who doesn't love their own child? Lại adds "of course", and mà works here too: ai mà không …. Often a topic comes first, closed by thì: Được nghỉ thì ai mà không thích? Who doesn't like a day off?
Nobody is meant to answer: agree, laugh or carry on talking. In Hà Nội you'll also hear ai chẳng or ai chả for "everybody": Ai chẳng biết! Everybody knows that!
Without mà or lại, a question with ai is usually a real one: Có ai biết đường không? Does anyone know the way? And ai cũng, which you know, says the same "everybody" calmly: Ai cũng thích được nghỉ. The question form says it with more feeling.
Examples
-
Ai mà biết!
Who knows!
-
Ai mà ngờ được!
Who'd have thought it!
-
Được nghỉ thì ai mà không thích?
Who doesn't like a day off?
-
Ai lại không thương con mình?
Who doesn't love their own child?